What Wars? What Roses?

- Episode 03-

‘Political gangsterdom’

A lively trade in hostages
27 March 2024
All History Café links
NEW SERIES What Wars? What Roses?
[photo] The church of St Martin, at Harfleur by Turner, at the Tate

Competent 15th Century kings went to war

In the 15th Century war was a means to quick profits (so long, of course, as you weren’t captured or killed.) Sensible soldiers teamed up and signed agreements to support each other if they were taken hostage, or worse.

The historian Kenneth McFarlane found one such agreement, signed by two young soldiers, Nicholas Molyneux and John Winter, in the summer of 1421 at the church of St Martin, Harfleur. They’d joined Henry V’s invasion of Normandy.

The agreement set out that, if either were taken prisoner —'which God forbid'— the other was bound to do everything possible to secure his freedom, provided that the ransom did not exceed £1,000 (a huge sum). If it did, then the free brother-in-arms would submit himself as a hostage, so that the captive could go home and raise the money.

Should both be captured at the same time, one would stay as a hostage while the other tried to fund the ransom for them both. (Hostage takers were clearly open to this sort of negotiation). 

McFarlane guessed that, in 1421, these two men can’t have been the humblest kind of foot soldiers. But when they signed the agreement they were probably still young, unmarried men, with enough cash to buy some basic military equipment and not much more. It's a rare insight into 15th century European war.



#94 'Political gangsterdom' - Ep 3 What Wars? What Roses?


[photo] 15th Century France: English land in pink, Burgundian in purple, French in blue

15th Century warfare was about capturing well connected people

Fifteenth century warfare was certainly about killing people. But it was much more about capturing them and then selling them for a ransom. There was a healthy black market in selling hostages on, and eventually extracting large sums from their families for their return.

Lord Fanhope, for example, bought a job lot of French prisoners from the Earl of Norfolk in 1421 and made so much money from selling them on that he built an entire new castle at Ampthill. (You won’t find that on the Royal Palaces website)
 
The going ransom rate was about a year’s worth of the hostage’s income but could be much more. For example Lord Moleyns was ransomed for £6 000 – an enormous sum, perhaps about £6 million today – in 1453. He then had to pay another £3,800 for the expense of imprisoning him. He finally got out in 1459.

Sieges were another way to make money – since many were ended when the beseiged castle or town bought the besiegers off. In 1428 the French garrison at Laval paid Lord Talbot £3,000 to go away.


[illustration] Henry V's soldiers storming the breach during the siege of Harfleur in 1415 painted by Thomas Grieve as part of the theatre design for Charles Kean's production of Henry V, 1859
Joan of Arc's greatest crime was to embarrass the English

 

[photo] Jehanne la Pucelle/ Joan the Maid

The catastrophic loss of England's French Empire was blamed on a 16-year old girl

When a young peasant girl turned up at the French court claiming to see seeing visions that would guide the French to victory against the English, she called herself Jehanne la Pucelle, Joan the Maid, and said she did not know her father’s surname. 

The new French king, Charles VII, son of the one who thought he was made of glass, was so convinced (or perhaps so desperate) that he packed the girl off to join his army, which was being besieged by the English at Orléans.

Nine days after she arrived, the English abandoned the siege. In fact, after a string of victories, Joan  found herself standing by Charles VII at his coronation as King of France.

But her career had lasted just a few days over two years when she was captured and handed over (or perhaps sold) to the English. She was tried by an ecclesiastical court in the English stronghold of Rouen (in pink area on map above).

After a year under threat of death (for being a heretic, fraud, sorceress and cross-dresser) she eventually put a ‘signature’ mark on a forced confession denying the visions in return for life imprisonment. Her very sudden volte-face to start wearing men’s clothing again, may have been because she realised that life in prison, as a plaything of the guards, would be unbearable.

On the morning of May 30, 1431, at the age of 19, she was burned at the stake in the old marketplace of Rouen.
 
The French still regard Jeanne d’Arc (her father's surname was a version of Arc) as their patron saint. 


 
[photo] Death trap of marshes and rivers surrounding Towton

The cruellest battle ever fought in England - at Towton in Yorkshire

It was Palm Sunday, 29 March 1461, when the armies of two kings met at Towton between Leeds and York. There may have been up to 50,000 men on the battlefield. 

The army of Henry VI (or rather the army of his French queen Margaret of Anjou) initially held the higher ground against the new 19-year old king, elected by parliament, Edward IV.  The Queen’s army was a third larger than Edward IV's, and with marshy ground and rivers on three sides, they expected to win.

Archeologists have reconstructed much of the battle from arrowheads and other weapons they’ve dug up. The battle turned when a strong wind began blowing snow into the faces of the Queen's army. In a battle where bows and arrows are key, a strong wind is serious. The Yorkists fought up and onto the high ground from where their arrows would carry much further, whilst Anjou's arrows were falling short.



Eventually the Anjou line broke and the Queen’s soldiers found themselves caught in the trap they had set for the Yorkists. There was nowhere to run except through the marshes and across the rivers. Many drowned. So many, it was said, that men were scrambling across the water on the dead bodies.

In his battles Edward had always called – as was normal - for ordinary soldiers to be spared. This time he called for no quarter.

Three quarters of (the few existing) English nobles had fought in the battle, most of them in fact on the queen’s side. Forty-two of her knights were captured and executed. Many others ended up in exile.

Queen Margaret fled to Scotland taking king Henry and their son with them. Oh, and also Henry’s servant Sir Richard Tunstall, who (as we have seen) may or may not have been the boy’s real father.
View All Episodes
Twitter
Facebook
Website
Spotify
Email
Copyright © 2024 History Cafe, All rights reserved.